Secondary Information: The Persistence and Absence of Criticism
March 19th, 2011
Fillip, Triple Canopy, and Queen’s Nails invite you to Secondary Information: The Persistence and Absence of Criticism, a discussion on contemporary art criticism with Bruno Fazzolari (Art Practical), Tara McDowell (The Exhibitionist), Julian Myers (California College of the Arts), Kristina Lee Podesva (Fillip), and Alexander Provan (Triple Canopy). This event will coincide with a launch for Fillip 13.
3191 Mission Street
Queen’s Nails Projects
San Francisco, CA 94110
Secondary Information brings together a small group of Bay Area writers and editors for a discussion with the editors of Fillip (Vancouver, BC) and Triple Canopy (New York, Los Angeles) about the numerous vehicles for, and approaches to, art criticism today, considering their value and significance vis-à-vis a spectrum of temporal and spatial contexts and engagements. How has the decentralization of publishing and the fragmentation of readerships affected art criticism? How are critical public spaces constituted around various forms of publication, whether online or in print? How might alternative forms of publication work to establish a critical position in relation to cultural production without necessarily engaging in conventional criticism? What is, and what should be, the role of criticism in relation to the speculative global art market and its preternatural ability to absorb, or cannibalize, oppositional discourses?
This discussion will take as points of departure Fillip and Artspeak’s Judgment and Contemporary Art Criticism book and forum (2009) and related texts, as well as Print and Demand, Triple Canopy’s ongoing series of conversations about how print culture is being changed by the manifold forms of online publication.
Participants
Bruno Fazzolari is an artist and critic. He has shown with Jancar Jones Gallery, Feature, Inc., and Michael Kohn Gallery. His work has received attention in Artforum, Art in America, the New Yorker, and the New York Times. He is a lecturer at the California College of the Arts. In the mid 1990s, his criticism appeared frequently in local, national, and international publications, now mostly defunct. After a twelve-year hiatus from criticism, his writing and interviews now appear regularly on Art Practical.
Art Practical is an online magazine that enriches critical dialogue for the visual arts by providing comprehensive analysis of events and exhibitions. Since its launch in October 2009, the journal has worked with a network of partners to promote the Bay Area’s role in the international art scene, to create a historical record of contemporary artistic practices, and to foster artistic production through critical writing and public programming.
Tara McDowell is Senior Editor of the Exhibitionist, a journal on curatorial practice and exhibition history published by Archive Books, Berlin. She is also a doctoral candidate in the History of Art at the University of California, Berkeley. She has held curatorial positions at the Wattis Institute for Contemporary Arts in San Francisco and the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art.
The Exhibitionist is a new journal that focuses solely on the practice of exhibition making. The objective is to create a wider platform for the discussion of curatorial concerns, encourage a diversification of curatorial models, and actively contribute to the formation of a theory of curating. The journal is a publication made by curators for curators, and understands itself as a site for critical debate in regards to exhibition practice and history.
Julian Myers is an art historian and critic whose essays have appeared in Documents, October, Afterall, Frieze, Fillip, Artforum, and elsewhere. He is an assistant professor at California College of the Arts and is on the editorial board of the Exhibitionist. He is based in San Francisco.
Kristina Lee Podesva is a Vancouver-based artist and writer, and editor of Fillip. Her works and writing have appeared in exhibition and publication projects throughout Canada, the United States, and Europe. Her writing has been published in Fillip and Bidoun, as well as in books such as Judgment and Contemporary Art Criticism, Komma (after Dalton Trumbo’s Johnny Got His Gun), and 100% Vancouver.
Alexander Provan is a writer living in Brooklyn. He is the editor of the online magazine
Triple Canopy is an online magazine, workspace, and platform for editorial and curatorial activities. Working collaboratively with writers, artists, and researchers, Triple Canopy facilitates projects that engage the Internet’s specific characteristics as a public forum and as a medium, one with its own evolving practices of reading and viewing, economies of attention, and modes of interaction. In doing so, Triple Canopy is charting an expanded field of publication, drawing on the history of print culture while acting as a hub for the exploration of emerging forms and the public spaces constituted around them.
Event History
2024
- Offprint Paris Art Book Fair 2024
- Acid-Free Lite: LA Art Book Market 2024
- Now Available: Gendered Labour and Clitoridean Revolt
- VABF Symposium on Art Publishing
- Vancouver Art Book Fair 2024
- San Francisco Art Book Fair 2024
- Offprint London 2024
- Seattle Art Book Fair 2024
- Ghent Art Book Fair 2024
- New York Art Book Fair 2024
- Multiple Formats Art Book Fair & Symposium 2024
- Reading Group: A Pragmatic Response to Real Circumstances with Anne Focke and Rhiannon Vogl
- Means of Production: Indigenous Patterns, Forms, and Letters with Kathleen and Christopher Sleboda
2023
- Tokyo Art Book Fair 2023
- Offprint Paris Art Book Fair 2023
- Volume 6 Montréal Art Book Fair
- LA Art Book Fair 2023
- San Francisco Art Book Fair 2023
- Post-Capitalist Architecture TV
- Otis MFA Graphic Design Art Book Fair
- Acid-Free LA Art Book Market
- Joar Nango & David Thomas in Dialogue: Supplement 7 at the Venice Biennale of Architecture
- Offprint London Art Book Fair 2023
- Seattle Art Book Fair
- Multiple Formats: Contemporary Art Book Symposium & Fair
- Print Pomona Art Book Fair
- Reading Group: Can one move along a number line? With Brynn McNab
2022
- Offprint Paris
- Tokyo Art Book Fair
- ACID-FREE Video Catalogue
- Two Hot Horses at the New York Art Book Fair
- Andrea Fraser and Helmut Draxler: In Dialogue
- Performance by Guillermo Galindo and Raven Chacon
- Volume Montréal
- Anthrozoology: Cats & Dogs
- Prairie Art Book Fair
- LIT LIT (The Little Literary Fair)
- San Francisco Art Book Fair
- Otis MFA Graphic Design Arts Book Fair
- The Unarius Academy of Science
- The Age of Unarius
- In Dialogue: Andrea Fraser and Pope.L
- Launch — S T R A Y . W O R L D
- E.S.P. — Parallel Transmissions
- Now Available: Services Working Group
2021
- Now Available: Institutions by Artists: Volume Two
- Conversation: On Gaslight
- Vancouver Art Book Fair
- E.S.P. — Anthrozoology
- Means of Production: The Employee with Joshua Schwebel
- Makeready: What Makes a Book a Book?
- Shannon Ebner: Stray World
- Project Series: Ian Wilson
- The Services Working Group
2020
- Moyra Davey: Two Hot Horses
- Kathleen Ritter: Gaslight
- Penny Slinger: Exorcisms
- E.S.P.: New Mineral Collective
- Means of Production: Sound, Silence, and Process with Guillermo Galindo & Raven Chacon
- Online Screening: Postmodern Times
- Means of Production: Community and the Work of Unworking with Am Johal
2019
- Means of Production: (In)consequential Thinking with Jacquelyn Zong-Li Ross
- E.S.P.: BeDevil
- Launch: Supplement 5: Mr. Peanut Summit
- E.S.P.: Ecologies
- Reading Group: Rebecca La Marre in Conversation with Tiziana La Melia
- Reading Group: The Culture Game with Patrick Cruz
- David Reinfurt: A *New* Program for Graphic Design
- E.S.P.: Visible Language Workshop
- Means of Production: Value Systems with Sarah Williams
- Stagelessness with Grupa o.k.
- E.S.P.: Visual Fields
2018
- Means of Production: On the Difficult with Jaclyn Bruneau
- Means of Production: Living as an Artist with Eli Bornowsky
- Means of Production: W.A.G.E. with Andrea Fraser
- Kandis WIlliams: Reproduction is Not a Metaphor
- Andrea Fraser: Museums, Money and Politics
- Means of Production: How to Make a Book with Steidl
- Means of Production: Photography as Tool with Winfried Heininger
- Listening Group: VWAM
- Means of Production: Research with Mercedes Eng
- Means of Production: Criticism with Steffanie Ling
- Reading Group: A History of Resistance with Grace Ndiritu
- Means of Production: Printing with Brick Press
- Reading Group: On Kathy Acker
- Chris Kraus on Kathy Acker
2017
- Reading Group: Nathan Crompton on Utopias
- Reading Group: Antonia Pinter
- Listening Group: The Red Krayola
- Supplement Launch: Berlin
- V-Girls: The Question of Manet's Olympia
- Hotel Theory Reader: Vancouver Launch
2016
- Reading Group: Zanna Gilbert
- Mr. Peanut Summit
- Reading Group: Grant Arnold
- Reading Group: Martine Syms
2015
- John C. Welchman: Joseph Kosuth's The Second Investigation in Vancouver
- SWARM XVI: Fillip, Punk 'til You Punk
- Eternal Network
2014
- Christopher Régimbal on Institutions by Artists
- Fillip Office Open House!
- Fillip 19 Launch and Screening
- Screening: The Hart of London
- Triple Canopy
2013
- Slide Shows at X Marks the Bökship
- Institutions by Arists Launch at Et al.
- Intangible Economies at Artists Space
2012
- Institutions by Artists
- Institutions by Artists: Print Centre
- Intangible Economies at Art Berlin Contemporary
- Sumi Ink Club
- Grouper: Sleep
- Robert Ashley Speaking Thru Will Holder
- Fillip 16: Berlin Launch
- Fillip 16: Toronto Launch
- Pa/per View Art Book Fair
- It's a Book, It's a Stage, It's a Public Place
- Destroy All Monsters Screening
- Fillip at ARCO Experts Forum
2011
- Intangible Economies
- Quiz Night
- David Horvitz: Room 129
- Recent Publications
- Of Times Recent and Distant
- Secondary Information: The Persistence and Absence of Criticism
2010
- The AAAARG Library
- Everything is Dangerous
- Fillip 12 Now Available
- Unter dem Motto
- International Chilliwack Biennial
- Motto Storefront: Ooga Booga
- Motto Storefront: Working Format
- Motto Storefront: Metahaven
- Motto Storefront: Oscar Tuazon
- Motto Storefront: Andjeas Ejiksson
- Motto Storefront: Avalanche Launch and Screening
- Motto Storefront: Rob Giampietro
- Motto Storefront: Stuart Bailey
- Motto Storefront
- John C. Welchman on Paul McCarthy’s Pirate Project
- David Horvitz Artist Talk
- Ryan Trecartin: Screening and Artist Talk
- Mark Manders: Window with Fake Newspapers and Traducing Ruddle
- Getting Something Into One's Head
- Fillip Review Panel: Vancouver Art Gallery’s Offsite, Anne Truitt, and Expanded Literary Practices
2009
- Autogestion Book Launch
- Antonia Hirsch at Space, London
- Silvia Kolbowski at Whitechapel Gallery
- Fillip Library and Reading Room Launch
- Fillip Summer Sale
- Corinn Gerber of Passenger Books
- Stockholm and Berlin Launches
- David Horvitz of ASDF
- Montréal Launch and Collaboration
- Issue Nine Vancouver Launch
- Judgment and Contemporary Art Criticism
- Fillip Review Panel: February 2009
2008
- Vancouver Launch of Two Artist Multiples
- The Apartment Inhabits the Fillip Studio
- Nick Thurston of Information as Material
- Rotterdam Dialogues: The Critics
- Fillip Review Panel: October 2008
- Stuart Bailey of Dexter Sinister
- Next: Documentary Perspectives in Contemporary Art
- Paul Chan Screening
- Issue Seven Vancouver Launch & Talk
- 22nd KIOSK Exhibition in Rennes
2007
- Fillip at castillo/corrales, Paris
- Fillip at the New York Art Book Fair
- LA Launch and Talk
- A History of Tokyo Art Speak
- Issue Five Vancouver Launch